To honor the career of one of the greatest NFL players of all time in Madden Ultimate Team, EA Sports has released three 24-hour only Peyton Manning player items representing different points of his career. The ratings on each item reflect his abilities and skill set at each point.
- Colts Legend (99 OVR)*
- Broncos Legend (98 OVR)
- Campus Legend (96 OVR)
*Best Pocket Passer In The Entire Game